CCC PPPPP U U CCC N N EEEEE W W W SSS C C P p U U C C NN N E W W W S S C P P U U C N N N E W W W S C PPPPP U U C N N N EEE W W W W SSS C P U U C N N N E WW WW S C C P U U C C N NN E W W S S CCC P UUUU CCC N N EEEEE W W SSS California Public Utilities Commission 505 Van Ness Avenue, Room 5301 San Francisco, CA 94102 CONTACT: Dianne Dienstein June 19, 1996 CPUC - 52 415-703-2423 (C. 88-03-016) CPUC APPROVES NAPA VALLEY WINE TRAIN EXPANSION The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) today approved expanded operation for the Napa Valley Wine Train and adopted an environmental mitigation and monitoring plan to resolve controversy between the Wine Train and communities along its route which has been ongoing since 1988. Since September 1989, the Wine Train has operated limited service between Napa and St. Helena. In July 1993, the Commission certified the Final Ennvironmental Impact Report (FEIR) required by the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The mitigation and monitoring plan requiring the Wine Train to operate under a specific set of conditions is geared to minimize potential environmental impacts of expanded operation. No trains is the baseline which will be used to determine the extent to which mitigation is necessary. The Wine Train will pay for mitigation of environmental impacts including increasing the length of turning lanes at SR29/Trower Avenue and Soscol Avenue/Third Street. The Commission determined that based on the FEIR, there will be no significant impacts identifiable if the Wine Train operates five trains/day and authorized it to begin doing so immediately. As monitoring is conducted to verify that impact levels are not exceeded, the Wine Train may eventually expand to six trains daily. It may also make up-valley stops as it meets requirements of local ordinances. Wine Train stops must be coordinated with and made pursuant to county or other local rules and regulations. - more - Local agencies may apply reasonable local ordinances to the Wine Train such as building code restrictions, but may not deny the Wine Train the right to operate or make stops. The Wine Train will not operate in the southern part of the Napa Valley on Friday evenings. The Wine Train may also contract with shuttle buses for prearranged trips coordinated with train schedules to nearby wineries and other attractions along fixed routes. However, at this time, it is uncertain whether it will do so. The Commission has overall responsibility for ensuring the mitigation plan meets CEQA guidelines. The Wine Train must provide funds which the CPUC will use to hire an independent Environmental Compliance Monitor which will monitor Wine Train compliance with today's Commission order and the FEIR and report directly to the Commission. Within the next 90 days, property owners living adjacent to the Wine Train who want landscaping or fencing improvements to obscure passengers' views of their property may request the Wine Train to make these improvements, and the improvements will be made within the next 180 days. The increased taxes, payroll, goods and services and potential to reduce the number of cars visiting the Napa Valley override concerns that there may be some air quality and noise impacts by expanded train operations. These impacts will be monitored to ensure they do not exceed threshold levels set by the FEIR. If noise levels increase 5 decibels over the present level of service, the Wine Train must take steps to reduce them as specified by the FEIR. If the City of St. Helena does not close McCorkle Avenue to public use, the Wine Train must install crossing gates so that it won't need to sound its horn at that location. The Wine Train is to hire a certified archaeologist during initial excavation and grading for parking areas to reduce the potential for cultural impacts. While the Wine Train has adequate toilet facilities on board the train for ordinary use, the potential impact on water supply in the area will be mitigated by requiring conversion of one toilet/winery located adjacent to the Wine Train route, and/or visited by passengers using shuttles in connection with Wine Train trips, to a low-flush type. The cost of conversion will be borne by the Wine Train, and must be in place within 180 days of the date the Wine Train begins to provide service to such a winery. ###