CCC PPPPP U U CCC N N EEEEE W W W SSS C C P p U U C C NN N E W W W S S C P P U U C N N N E W W W S C PPPPP U U C N N N EEE W W W W SSS C P U U C N N N E WW WW S C C P U U C C N NN E W W S S COC P UUUU CCC N N EEEEE W W SSS California Public Utilities Commission 505 Van Ness Avenue, Room 5301 San Francisco, CA 94102 CONTACT: Armando Rendon September 20, 1996 CPUC-076 415-703-1366 (I94-06-012) CPUC PROPOSES TREE TRIMMING RULES FOR ELECTRIC UTILITIES The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) today, striving to curtail the tree-related outages and fires that have recently plagued California, proposed rules that would require the state's electric utilities to speed up the trimming or removal of trees near power lines. Finding the existing tree trimming rules in need of modification, the Commission proposed to adopt the clearances presented in a settlement between the CPUC's Safety Branch staff and the electric distribution utilities. Although the settlement was opposed, the Commission proposed to adopt the clearances because of the urgency to assure public safety and the reliability of the electricity distribution system. The Commission proposed the settlement rules today with the intent of issuing the interim rules before December. Its order also launches a further inquiry into the development of permanent rules which it would adopt next year. Specific standards for separation between live power lines and trees or shrubs were proposed: Rule 37 of General Order 95 adds a minimum separation of six inches between line conductors and vegetation under normal conditions for circuits carrying between 750 to 35,000 volts. Distance from vegetation at the time of trimming would depend on the voltage of a given line: 2,400 to 72,000 volts, 4 feet of clearance; up to 110,000 volts, 6 feet; up to 300,000 volts, 10 feet, and, for 300,000 or more volts, a new standard set in the settlement, 15 feet. The Commission emphasized that it was concerned about adopting a clearance standard of six inches, even on an interim basis, but the standard was only a minimum and not the distance -more- to which foliage must be pruned. It proposes to develop a more complete record to justify permanent clearances, and seeks comment on whether the minimum clearances in the Public Resources Code are reasonable--the Code provides for minimum clearances of at least 4 feet in rural and forested areas. The utilities affected, Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E), Southern California Edison (SCE), San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E), Pacific Power and Light, and Sierra Pacific Power Company, are to reach full compliance with Rule 37 changes in 25 percent increments each six months through September 1998. The CPUC's Energy Division will monitor progress and is directed to take prompt enforcement action against utilities which fail to meet the Commission's timetable. The CPUC's review of safety aspects of tree trimming practices was initially prompted by the accidental electrocution in 1992 of a farmworker trimming trees near SDG&E power lines. Because the incident raised general concerns about tree trimming practices, the CPUC split off a separate proceeding in June 1994 just to deal with tree trimming issues. Two major outages this summer originated outside the state due to trees coming in contact with power lines, but numerous outages and related fires, one a devastating blaze in Sonoma County recently, have also occurred in California because of trees growing too close to power lines. ###